Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Lessons from Cairo

I think most of us would be hard-pressed not to be inspired by the moral power of the crowds in people in Egypt as they throw off a form of government that they find repressive. But, it is about the US reaction to all this to which I turn today. It is the subject of New York Times columns by David Brooks and Nicholas D. Kristof.

Both authors noted the ham-handed manner in which the United States deals with authoritarian regimes and with popular movements for freedom.

Brooks notes,

The . . . thing we’ve learned is that the United States usually gets everything wrong.

Policy makers always underestimate the power of the bottom-up quest for dignity, so they are slow to understand what is happening.

Then their instinct is to comfort the fellow members of the club of those in power.

Then, desperately recalibrating in an effort to keep up with events, they inevitably make a series of subtle distinctions no one else heeds.

Kristof says,

Yet one thing nags at me. These pro-democracy protesters say overwhelmingly that America is on the side of President Mubarak and not with them. They feel that way partly because American policy statements seem so nervous, so carefully calculated.

The upshot is that this pro-democracy movement, full of courage and idealism and speaking the language of 1776, wasn’t inspired by us. No, the Egyptians said they feel inspired by Tunisia — and a bit stymied by America.

Everywhere I go, Egyptians insist to me that Americans shouldn’t perceive their movement as a threat. And I find it sad that Egyptians are lecturing Americans on the virtues of democracy.

Brooks provided a broader context for all of this:

I wonder if sometime around 50 years ago a great mental tide began to sweep across the world. Before the tide, people saw themselves in certain fixed places in the social order. They accepted opinions from trusted authorities.

As the tide swept through, they began to see themselves differently. They felt they should express their own views, and these views deserved respect. They mentally bumped themselves up to first class and had a different set of expectations of how they should be treated. Treatment that had once seemed normal now felt like an insult. They began to march for responsive government and democracy.

You will excuse me if I draw the connection to health care. I hope you don't think it inapposite.

I do not think that it has been a fifty year trend in health care, but a more recent one. Patients and families have decided that they should be equal partners in the process of diagnosis and treatment. They believe that they have a right to the information that can represent life or death, health or suffering. As Brooks would put it, "treatment that once seemed normal now feels like a insult." Opinions from trusted authorities no longer carry the weight they used to. Questions are being asked. Answers are being demanded.

A few weeks ago, author Charles Kenney asked the question, Isn't there a compelling -- perhaps even overriding -- moral component to transparency?

I responded,

The answer, of course, is yes. Doctors and others pledge to do no harm. How can you be sure you are living by that oath if you are unwilling to acknowledge how well you are actually doing the job? As scientists, how can you test to see if you are making improvements in evidence-based care if you cannot validate the "prior" against which you are testing a new hypothesis? At the most personal, ethical level, how can you be sure you are doing the best for people who have entrusted their lives to you if you are not willing to be open on these matters?

But transparency threatens the status quo. In the medical world, status quo confers power, influence, prestige, and money on those who have had a reputational advantage. A close friend and colleague put it this way:

Transparency in self-interested institutions who are making fortunes by deluding themselves and the public that they and only they know what the community wants and needs is a very dangerous concept.

The agents of change in this battle will be the same people who are turning things over in Egypt. Normal people who have experienced pain and suffering, or even just disrespect, in the health care system are starting to find their voice. Like the US in the international arena, the powers that be in the government and their agents, having been captured by the powerful forces of the medical and hospital profession, are slow to react and are protective of the status quo.

Policy makers always underestimate the power of the bottom-up quest for dignity, so they are slow to understand what is happening.

Then their instinct is to comfort the fellow members of the club of those in power.

Then, desperately recalibrating in an effort to keep up with events, they inevitably make a series of subtle distinctions no one else heeds.

Monday, January 31, 2011

Tectonic forces at work

We are about to witness the clash of two tectonic plates in health care. The creation of Accountable Care Organizations, combined with a movement towards capitated and other types of bundled payments, will be forces towards integration of care across the continuum. From primary care to tertiary care to skilled nursing and rehabilitation, principles of care management will combine with financial incentives to create ever more concentration in the health care market. Proprietary electronic medical records systems and "captive" doctor organizations will work towards reducing consumer choice in this new environment.

You already see health care companies engaged in this and advertising it as an attribute. Here, for example, one company notes: [Q]uality care is not just about the care in one institution – it’s what happens between institutions. And if we don’t pay close attention to those gaps – which means measuring and acting to improve the information flow – the patient will suffer. (And, you already see health care companies engage in deceptive behavior with regard to referrals, too, like here.)

Yet, at the same time, patients and their advocates will be demanding more choice. Fully trained in consumerism in other fields, they will expect the same in health care. They will want internet-based transparency of clinical outcomes, along with tons of disease-specific information, so they can seek out and obtain the best possible care for themselves and their loved ones. They will press captive doctors to allow them to be referred to out-of-network health care companies that appear to provide better, safer, and/or more compassionate care.

How will this crash of the tectonic plates be resolved? One answer is to ignore consumer preference and rely on monopoly-like organization of care. We know from other fields, however, that this not only results in monopoly pricing, but it slows down innovation. Think of the Bell System in years past, which provided integrated service, from telephone instruments to long distance calling. Many people alive today do not know that the Bell System conspired to limit people's choice to the extent that you were not allowed to connect a non-Bell telephone in your house. The company argued that doing so would cause irreparable harm to the network and knock out telephone service for miles! You could not buy your phone. You had to rent it for a monthly fee, payable forever (see below). Actually, it was even worse than that. Your bill also included a fee for every extension outlet in your house, even outlets that did not have telephones attached.


And, if you wanted to make a long distance call, there was only one provider, AT&T Long Lines, the one affiliated with your local Bell operating company. You paid by the minute: There was no unlimited service based on a fixed monthly fee. Why? Because they could.

Eventually, the government broke up the Bell System when upstart competitors wanted to sell telephone sets and other companies wanted to offer long distance service. Standards were established that allowed anyone to use the local network and get access to dial tone. Eventually, even that monopoly was broken when other telephone companies and cable companies were permitted to string wires into the neighborhoods. And then, even those technologies faced competition from cellular networks and voice-over-internet.

Is there a lesson from all this for health care? You bet.

The heart of the problem in health care has two dimensions. First, electronic medical records are often based on proprietary systems, limiting interoperability between health care networks. Second, doctors are captive members of a provider network, often one controlled by a region's major hospital or health care company.

As computer guru John Halamka would note, the first problem is gradually going away, in a technical sense. With the advent of national data standards, it will be easier and easier to electronically connect patient records across multiple providers. There are already clear demonstrations of full integration in place, where two or more organizations have found it to be in their mutual interest. But we can expect geographically strong networks to resist this. It will take government action to enforce interoperability.

The second problem, though, requires a Bell System-like solution. As long as physician groups are owned by or otherwise financially affiliated with hospitals, the doctors in those groups will not have the freedom to refer folks to the facilities that are optimal for patients. We can make all the claims we want about the need to have a closely tied physician network to provide integrated health care delivery, but those claims are vacuous. Such systems tend to be driven by -- and serve -- the hospitals and the specialists in them rather than the community-based physicians.

Ask this question to any primary care doctor you know who is part of a hospital-based network: "Do you feel you have the freedom to send a patient to a hospital in another network? " At best, they will say, "If I really feel strongly about it, I can do so." But, if they are honest, they will say, "I don't dare do that very often, if at all. My continued participation in the contracting benefits of my network depend on sending my patients to affiliates in that network."

It is time to break this system wide open and prohibit corporate affiliations between community-based providers and hospital-based health care delivery networks. Let's free up the community doctors to make referral choices based on publicly available data about clinical outcomes, quality of service, and other items that matter to their patients. If global payments become the norm, the PCPs should "own" the payment and then apportion it among secondary and tertiary providers who best serve their patients. Let the marketplace decide which hospitals rise or fall in this environment.

Short of that, we will retain Ma Bell in health care. Then, the answer will be the one given by Lily Tomlin (aka, Ernestine, the telephone company operator):

"Next time you complain about your phone service, why don't you try using two Dixie cups with a string. We don't care. We don't have to. We're the Phone Company!"

If you cannot see the video below, click here.

Sunday, January 30, 2011

Should there be a billing code for compassionate care?

Back in 2009, Dr. Amy Ship gave a moving acceptance speech when she received the annual Compassionate Caregiver Award from the Schwartz Center.

The most memorable tag line from the speech was, "There is no billing code for compassion." This resonated with so many of us -- patients and providers -- in part because it set forth the proposition that compassionate care should be an inherent aspect of medical services. The idea that some portion of a doctor's or hospital's payment should be tied to such an essential human value seemed ludicrous.

Or is it? A recent survey conducted by the Schwartz Center, entitled "The state of compassionate care in the United States," indirectly raises the issue. Those patients and doctors surveyed were overwhelmingly in favor of the idea that compassionate care was important to the successful treatment of patients. They agreed, too, that compassionate care makes a difference in how well a patient recovers from illness. Indeed, they believed that good communication and emotional support can make a difference in whether a patient lives or dies.

But there was a gap between what patients said was most important to them, in terms of compassionate care, and what they actually experienced during recent hospitalizations. And, looking forward, both patients and doctors are worried that the changes being made in our health care system will make it more difficult for providers to offer compassionate care.

Now, if we remove the word "compassionate" from the above discussion and instead insert "safety," "quality," "avoiding hospital acquired infections," or the like, our immediate response would be that we need to change the system of hospital and physician payments to provide financial incentives to change things for the better. Whether we might propose a pay-for-performance approach or some kind of global payment to encourage improvement, the current environment seems very comfortable with using the payment system to nudge behavior in the right direction.

So, why not pay for compassion? Surely, we can name those aspects of care that are most closely tied to compassion, and we can likewise document whether they occur.

While I will let this debate play out in the comments below, let me start it off by saying that I believe this would be a mistake. So many discrete aspects of medical care are already monetized that is hard to imagine a payment regime that would actually focus sufficient financial attention to motivate a doctor along the spectrum of less-to-more compassion. Beyond that, the idealist in me is offended by the idea of paying someone to, in essence, be more humane. In my view, this is not a matter of remuneration. It is a matter of societal values and a training program and ongoing supervision that imbues practice with those values.

But, let's hear what you have to say. Should there be a billing code for compassionate care?

Unguarded waterfront

An important warning at Walden Pond, in case you were thinking of swimming yesterday.

Throw the snow in the Harbor!

As I was walking home last night, I saw this scene on Arlington Street in downtown Boston. I was reminded of a story I heard the other day on WBUR's Radio Boston about the problems being faced by Boston and other communities as they engage in snow removal from municipal streets. One aspect of the problem is that state environmental officials have prohibited Boston and other coastal communities from disposing of street snow in the Harbor.

Now, I don't think anyone can contest my environmental bona fide's. After all, I ran the agency that accomplished the Boston Harbor Cleanup, one of the world's largest environmental remediation projects. But this is one rule that I just don't understand.

Yes, I know that snow on city streets picks up all kinds of chemicals and pollutants from the city environment, and I know it also picks up salt and chemical de-icers during its residence time.

But, instead of dumping this snow in the harbor, it gets trucked -- using thousands of gallons of fuel which create all kinds of air emissions -- to inland locations. What happens there? It melts, and those same pollutants enter the ground water system. Or they go into city storm drains, where they end up where? Boston Harbor.

Perchance some of the melted snow goes down storm drains that empty into the city's combined system, which sends the wastewater to the Deer Island sewage treatment plant. In that case, such contaminants that are captured are concentrated in the sludge at the plant, which is eventually made into fertilizer, from which the chemicals leach out onto farmland somewhere. The contaminants that are not captured in the sludge go out through a tunnel 9.5 miles long with the plant's effluent to Massachusetts Bay, the receiving water for . . . Boston Harbor.

I just don't see the point. Why don't we save the extra expense so Boston and other coastal communities can use that money for things like environmental education in the local schools?

When snow falls from the sky, it goes directly into the Harbor. Let's follow Nature's lead.

Standard of review

A comment by an eight-year-old girl, exiting last night's tap dance performance by Savion Glover: "That was better than American Idol!"

Saturday, January 29, 2011

Mystery Photo 3: Not Uluru but Kata Tjuta

     I received a couple of guesses on this place, on my Facebook account. As I warned you, you all might think it is a different place. You might think it is Uluru in the outback of Australia. Well, you are very close. It is in the outback of Australia about 16 miles east of Uluru. It is Kata Tjuta, also known as the Olgas. It is a group of large domed rock formations called bornhardts, like Uluru/Ayer's Rock). They are made of the same rock called a conglomerate which includes granite and basalt cobbles embedded in sandstone. All these cobbles are cemented together by this dramatic red sandstone. There are 36 separate domes in this formation unlike Uluru which is one megalith. The highest dome of the Olgas is 3,497 feet (1066 meters) above sea level, and about 1791 feet (546 m) above the surrounding plain. That height is 650 ft (198 m) higher than the neighboring Uluru. The tallest dome is called Mount Olga, name in 1872 by Ernest Giles in honor of Queen Olga of Wurttemberg. In 1993, a policy was adopted that allows both the traditional Aboriginal name and the English name to be used.





     Above are several views of the Olgas. There are several trails that intertwine among them. I wished we had had more time to hike among them. Below is a satellite photo of Kata Tjuta/ the Olgas showing how extensive these 36 domes are.


     Now of course I have a lot of photos of Uluru, 16 miles distant showing the effects of the various lighting on the monolith. Hit Read More below to see photos and read about Uluru, the better known of these sandstone monuments in the Australian outback near Alyce Springs.



     There is an interesting touristy tradition at Uluru which involves parking in one of the bays along the Ring Road around Uluru, and having champagne and canapes, or in some cases even a buffet supper while watching the sunset over the monolith. I tried to find where this custom came from but it no doubt came from a group of tourists that happened along, parked for sunset and decided to tip a few glasses. It certainly didn't come from the Aboriginal peoples. They have many restricted areas around Uluru and actually along with the Australian government put a ban on all alcohol products in the park in 2007. There was concern that many young girls had been sexually molested in some of the small Aboriginal villages around the base of Uluru. The blame was placed on tourists bringing alcohol into the area. For a while you could only drink alcohol if you were a member of a tour bus group in the special parking lot for buses. But apparently the Aboriginals backed down and attributed the sexual cases to a local who had since moved on and the government had to lighten up because tourism was being affected. At any rate, this custom is back in full swing. The only limitations now are that you are not allowed to just park along the road; you must pull into one of the 4 parking areas provided for this. And you are not allowed to walk off into the sand dunes or areas off the road. We did enjoy the sunset very much there. It must be one of the most rewarding views at that time of day in the world. The naturally red sandstone becomes unbelievable hues as the light changes. The following photos just give a hint of those vivid tones.



     The local tribe of Aboriginal people is called the Anangu. For them, Uluru and Kata Tjuta are very sacred places. There are many folk tales and creation stories that are told about especially Uluru. The shamans of the Anangu do not allow these stories to be told to outsiders. But sometimes they do get out. Since Australia has made an effort to allow the Anangu to decide what is allowed and what is not allowed these restrictions are usually abided by. Some areas are not to be photographed because they are exclusively for either women or men of the tribe and photos would allow the opposite sex to see the restricted area of the other sex. The Anangu who do not climb the sacred monolith,  have reluctantly allowed outsiders to climb Uluru, but only in this one area. The base of this trail is shown below.



Below are two photos that demonstrate how the color tones can change as the sun sets.




     There are many small canyons and caves along the periphery of Uluru. We tourists are allowed to enter this particular cave. It shows a good example of the cave painting that is present in many of these places. You will see examples in the next two photos. A sign at this site says: "A Home Becomes a Gallery. You are standing where parents have taught their children for 1000s of years. These abstract symbols illustrate stories in every day lives of each genereation of the Anangu. Every symbol has many different levels of meaning and can help illustrate different stories. However, the original purpose of a symbol was only known to the artist who painted it."
     The Anangu tribe and their ancestors have been living in this area for at least 5000 years, and some knowledgeable in study of the origins of peoples think they lived here almost as they do now 10,000 years ago. Many Western tourists visiting this cave ask from when the paintings date. The Anangu do not have the same relationship with time that we do. There are no doubt marks here that were made many hundreds and maybe thousands of years ago, but there are also marks that were made very recently. The Anangu just write on top of previously made marks. They do not feel the need to preserve the old marks without alteration that we feel.



     Our guide told us a story about the Aboriginal people that demonstrates the difference between their and our culture. An Australian farmer of European descent was out hand plowing his field one day. He was walking back and forth behind the plow and sweating and suffering the whole day. All of this time, an Aboriginal man was sitting under a tree at the edge of the field and just watching the farmer. The farmer came over the man and said, "If you come with me, I will teach you how to do this plowing. Then if you stick with it and plow this whole field, I will pay you some money that we agree on and you will be earning some money for your family. If you do a good job, you can come back to me tomorrow and all through the planting season and help me. You will earn a lot of money and you will be able to send you children to a better school. And you will be able to put aside money for later in your life. Then you can retire and just sit around doing nothing then."
     The Aboriginal man looked strangely at the farmer and said, "But that last is what I have already been doing all today. Didn't you see me? And I didn't have to work at all."
     This culture usually does not look to the future. They do what they can to get their food for that day, such as hunting and gathering, or perhaps working at an odd job for money for that day. Then when they have accomplished that they stop working and sit down to rest. Just as this story indicates, there is no thought to working for the future or to putting away money or even food for the future. That is one reason that the Western culture and the Aboriginal culture have such a hard time mixing.
      Above is a photo of the other side of Uluru. If looked at from the top, it is actually sort of a trigular shape. There seem to be fewer canyons and indentations on this side of the Rock.


      Below is another resident of this area. He posed very nicely for us. After searching on the Internet, I have decided this is one of the species of sand monitor or goanna lizards that are very common in the Australian outback. They are preditors, have sharp teeth and claws, and eat small mammals and bugs. They burrow to look for food, and to nest. They also frequently stand on their hind feet and even sometimes are seen to run only on their hind feet. They readily get used to people; hence this one posing calmly for us in this area of many tourists.

     Below is the Anangu Culture Center with some representations of their art, which is of distinctive style. It is often a very large pointillism which tells stories about daily life of the people here. For example the large circles of dots would each represent people. So this is likely the story of a trip with multiple people. The one below actually shows the footprints of the journeys of the people being represented. 



      Below is an Anangu artist displaying her work near the Visitor Center. We purchased the piece that the lady is holding with me along side. After taking her picture with the piece, we learned that she was just selling these; the artist was an Anangu man who was seen elsewhere among the displays but we did not get his photo. The piece that this lady is holding up tells the story of two women as evidenced by the boomerang and circle shapes. These women would be sitting on their haunches and these are roughly the indentations in the sand that their bodies would make. One long oblong is a knife and the other is a plate like recepticle. These two women have gone hunting for desert bananas as they are called. The central circle represents the banana vine and its branches. We now have this piece framed in our home representing to us and our visitors the art of this very interesting people and our visit to Kata Tjuta and Uluru.